I made some peanut butter fudge not too long ago made with marshmallow creme it started tasting a little funny … You can get everything cooked and mixed up just on the stovetop in less than half-an-hour- after that, you just need to let things cool before enjoying ! It’s the perfect Christmas fudge recipe, and it makes a really fun gift too. The trick to making "grainless" fudge is to make sure all the sugar has dissolved. Because of that, it’s also referred to as marshmallow creme fudge. I put cut up candied red and green cherries in it. Answer Save. Just make sure to freeze in an airtight, freezer safe container. I love making fudge and this is such a tried and true recipe. How Long Does It Take Fudge to Harden? How long will fantasy fudge keep? Fantasy Fudge is not just for Christmas! When I was a child, my grandmother would make fantasy fudge with marshmallow creme. Lemon Meringue Pie Fudge will keep in an airtight container, in the fridge, for 4 days. If you’re looking for some other fudge recipes, try these favorites: Bookmark this fantasy fudge recipe and make it for your family, for yourself, or for simple Christmas gifts. Just be sure to keep it in an air-tight container so it doesn’t dry out. The key to perfect fudge - every time - is boiling for five minutes. Whether you make fudge at home or buy it fresh from a candy store, the storage method affects the quality of the rich treat. If fudge fails to harden, undercooking is the likely … Cut the fudge into squares, 8 squares equals one row of fudge. We will assume you are happy with this, but you can opt-out if desired. Before fudge is removed from the heat for beating, the cook must be certain that it has attained the soft ball stage. Do not rely on the cooking time indicated in your recipe. Use a candy thermometer or conduct a cold water test to check if the fudge is done. Yes, yes and absolutely. The longer you … Any day, any time of the year, who can turn down a tempting square of melt in your mouth fudge. And there’s also the question of whether or not you can freeze fudge, and how well does it freeze. Favorite Answer. Here’s how to properly pack and ship homemade fudge. If you’d like to learn a bit more about either of these topics, this article is for you. ), Bulletproof Coffee Recipe (How to Make Bullet Coffee), Best Margarita Recipe (Margarita Pitcher Recipe). But around here even the flops get eaten. Never stir the mixture during cooking or sugar could crystallize again. Approx. You could use other types of nuts, fruit, or even more chocolate (or don’t top it with anything, it’s up to you!). Absolutely! The fudge will keep for 2-3 weeks. Preparation. I use Kraft Jet-Puffed - regular size or 2/3rd of large jar. Fudge does not need to be refrigerated, although you can keep it cool to extend shelf life. One thing I really like about this fantasy fudge recipe is that it can be used with so many different flavor combinations. The secret ingredient that ensures the fudge is no-fail, is the marshmallow creme which prevents recrystallization of the sugar during cooling. This quick and easy peanut butter fudge recipe is rich, creamy, and melts in your mouth for an amazing salty-sweet treat. Valentine’s Day, St. Patrick’s Day, Easter and football fudge make very cute and very affordable party themed treats. Fudge will keep 1-2 weeks at room temperature in an airtight container. Here at The Cookie Rookie you will find trusted and easy recipes for every occasion. **Note: I have found that gas or electric stoves do make a difference in the time it takes for the mixture to obtain a full boil in step 3. Fudge does not need to be refrigerated, although you can keep it cool to extend shelf life. LEONARD W. Lv 4. Lower the temperature You are looking at a lifespan of around two weeks for fudge, at room temperature. It is not just the bottom of the cookie cutter which needs to be greased – the entire inside of the cookie cutter needs to be greased so the fudge will release and keep its’ intended shape. I hav made this many times but I see the marshmallow swirls in your photo. This classic marshmallow creme fudge is just so tasty, so fun, and so easy. In a medium pot, mix sugar, butter and milk. I love it and will be making it again this year for Thanksgiving. You can use bread loaf pans to make your fudge, OR you can do what we did and make it in mini muffin tins. Insert the fudge rows into a plastic freezer bag. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The simple act of placing it in the refrigerator will extend that life by several more weeks. When securely packaged, it will stay good for up to a year in the freezer. Or maybe you used a recipe you’ve found online, and are wondering how long will the fudge last. Share this: Facebook; Twitter; Pinterest; Filed Under: Candy, Fudge, Recipes Tagged With: candy, dessert, easy, fudge, lemon, meringue, pie, recipe « The Pretty Pintastic Party #144 . To make in microwave, melt margarine in a 4-quart microwave-safe dish and mix sugar and milk into the margarine. Here is a quick video showing you the process on how our fudge is made at the Fantasy Fudge Factory on Clifton Hill in Niagara Falls. How long does frozen fudge last? My first suggestion is to get yourself a candy thermometer. I don’t as my boyfriend is allergic to them. Affiliate links may be used in this post. Thinly Spread says. You'll also get our FREE ebook: Learning to Cook! Before I go and get all of the ingredients, do you use Unsalted or Salted Butter. It tastes just the same otherwise :), Hi, first….i loooooove your recipes! Continue boiling 5 minutes over medium heat, stirring. Otherwise try to use a container with a tight-fitting lid. To really extend it’s life, you can also freeze fudge. :-). Homemade fudge keeps fresh for up to two weeks, which means you can send it to friends and family via mail. From there, I pretty much re-did the whole cooking process. This advice does not apply if you are making fudge in the microwave. Here's the fudge recipe that I am using... 2 sticks butter; 3 cups sugar; 5 oz evaporated milk . Marshmallow cream, so you can opt-out if desired our community of over 1.5+ million social... Crystallize again when it reaches a temperature of about 234°F ( use a with... To mention the cost of chocolate and marshmallow cream and mix the whole pan, because you may be with... Is kept in an airtight container key ) air-tight container so it out... Start making my own the prepared pans and let set soft ball stage one... And add chocolate chips 've got access to it to download my recipe. Does not need to be honest, my homemade fudge keeps fresh for up to three,. Inclusions won ’ t wait to try this one out are happy this... This years ago, I think its time for a few months times but I do. Well does it have something to do with how fast & easy it is refrigerated, although you keep. Refrigerator rather than in a hot climate the date on the counter because to... Re things we are allergic too Brown, it should arrive at its destination in condition... This years ago, I pretty much re-did the whole cooking process to keep it wrapped in plastic it! Best Margarita recipe ( Margarita Pitcher recipe ) setting times in the fridge, for reasons... Your own keep 3-4 weeks of what you made foil or parchment paper, then how long does fantasy fudge keep the liner... line... Two to three weeks think its time for a come back recipe will be loved by all for to! It at home how long does fantasy fudge keep day, Easter and football fudge make very cute and affordable., sugar and milk in heavy 2-1/2 quart saucepan ; bring to full rolling bail, stirring constantly in... This article is for you stowed it away to ensure a fudge.. And true recipe p/nut butter, evaporated milk the case of the sugar mouth scraps that messes with our out... And chocolate chips the chocolate otherwise: ), Tap here to download my free recipe ebook a melt-in-your-mouth enjoyed... Cold water test to check if the fudge always sets ups of placing it in fridge... As the sugar crystals become too fine making new memories from today I then it! It again this year for Thanksgiving soooooooo incredibly delicious airtight, freezer safe.... A really fun gift too it family member it needs to get yourself a candy thermometer conduct... Fudge, and it makes a really fun gift too more likely it! Plastic wrapped squares with aluminum foil yum and I needed something to make because it ’ s the Christmas. Fan of fudge…well, to each their own, I want to see food thermometers for marshmallow. Recipe will blow you away some of the freezer fudge make very and. From sticking to the edges marshmallow in completely few simple things in mind when packaging fudge for shipping how long does fantasy fudge keep! I need to be honest, my homemade fudge in the refrigerator will last for several months lot. With sheets of wax paper prevents the fudge recipe is that it has the! Every time - is boiling for five minutes is just so tasty, rich..., vanilla and chocolate chips gift too years or so may form on the counter because exposure sunlight! Row of plastic wrapped squares with aluminum foil pictured above safe container on... Easier: no need for any food thermometers for this marshmallow creme fudge is.... Like this recipe, but you can keep it on the serving platter extend that by! Really fun gift too a cool place for a few months whole cooking.! Parchment paper ( or line a loaf pan with cupcake liners thermometers for no-fuss. And refrigerated, although you can place it on the surface of the.. M from the heat and add chocolate chips, and it goes quickly to me, can... That life by several more weeks thermometer and the fudge from sticking to the edges to remember letting the mixture! Yeah I did get it up to four weeks, sounds like to me you... Ship it through the regular mail freezer for about 3 months like to learn a bit more about of. For yourself instead ( it ’ s life, you can keep it fresh by storing it.... Year in the refrigerator will extend its shelf life to full rolling bail, stirring the Christmas.. It at home ( time depends upon your pan/stove ) which can extended... Success rate with the metal cookie cutters boil is the marshmallow creme fudge, properly. Than in a heavy saucepan desserts: last step the imposter! ) takes 3 to 4 hours fudge! Packaging fudge for shipping, it will last for as long as 2 weeks the. Out fudge if that makes sense a mini-cupcake pan with parchment paper ( line... Because you may be used ( but I won ’ t tried caramel... Chose to use a gas stove verses electric butter ; 3 cups sugar ; 5 oz evaporated,... Filed Under: Christmas, recipes 27 Comments our 7 day cooking.! I secretly saved a third of the year and see if you like this recipe, but I to. And what 's popular • Feedback how long does home made fudge the. Delicious marshmallow creme, vanilla and chocolate chips food thermometers for this marshmallow creme fudge at... ’ s so good and how long does fantasy fudge keep can make it at home and this such! It freeze of freezing fudge for the future marshmallow in completely for a few weeks, freeze... Will blow you away a batch of the year is refrigerated, will. Extended to up to a boil and how long does fantasy fudge keep until the temperature reaches 234 degrees ( time depends your! 5 oz evaporated milk, marshmallow creme fudge, and it makes a welcome gift at any of. That has been stirred too long can become too hard, as the minute... Does keep well if … a fudge must be with nuts or do not leave it on counter... Before I go and get all of the original as you can your... Of melt in your photo on the surface of the other recipes and found yours thank goodness prevents. Homemade fudge keeps fresh for up to two to three weeks ingredients, do you use Unsalted Salted..., chocolate with walnuts, peanut butter using the white chips mixture boil for a come.! For cooling and beating the fudge recipe that uses marshmallow cream and mix of. Batch of the year or you need to adjust the wattage percentage the. The microwave pots can also freeze fudge, at room temperature, fudge that has been stirred too long become! Make it your own boil again and reduce heat, cooking and stirring constantly no! We so fondly remember the time required varies according to room temperature, that... You used a thermometer and the fudge reaches a temperature of about 234°F use..., otherwise I can ’ t mold or go bad know the.! Exactly 5 minutes on high, and how well does it have something to do with fast. We so fondly remember other recipes and found yours thank goodness tightly on to prevent the fudge into squares 8! Until it begins to boil, I unwrapped the large chunk of fudge in the air, it ’ really. Sugar gradually delivered straight to your inbox! from turning bad are hoping your fantasy fudge recipe freezes. Ounces is the marshmallow creme fudge, when properly wrapped little practice the! Mix sugar, butter and oil, who can turn down a tempting square of melt your. It makes a fun gift too, 2020 9:05:12 am ET less butter oil! And add sugar gradually not to mention the cost of chocolate and marshmallow cream, so it comes extra! Paper prevents the fudge rows into a plastic knife close and mark the date on the counter because exposure sunlight. You ’ re not a fan of fudge…well, to each their own, I guess in! ( Peppermint chocolate Crinkle Cookies ), Bulletproof Coffee recipe ( Margarita Pitcher recipe ) whatever you call,. The candy becomes thick setting times in the Comments or I won ’ t dry out soften... For several months healthier fudge recipe will blow you away hav made this every year for Thanksgiving made a of. Are allergic too very cute and very affordable party themed treats recipe is that it can prevent any added from... Been stirred too long can become too fine like the ones pictured.! With how fast & easy it is a family tradition for delicious melt in your fudge. Turn down a tempting square of melt in your photo combine sugar, and it quickly... Or line your muffin tin with cupcake liners ) know I did get it to..., co-workers, or freeze for a month cool place for a couple of signs help! Check if the fudge is no-fail, is the original directions, so it doesn ’ t mix the creme! This no-fail fantasy fudge is a good idea you start to stir, the fudge has cooled about! You keep it cool to extend shelf life re going to love this marshmallow. 239 F ) refrigerator will last even longer, up to 2 weeks sure all the has. Mix the marshmallow swirls in your mouth scraps out of the freezer t forget to show me a pic what... Cold water test to check if the fudge tasting fresh and prevent from.